The accordion component delivers large amounts of content in a small space through progressive disclosure. Raluca Budiu is Director of Research at Nielsen Norman Group, where she consults for clients from a variety of industries and presents tutorials on mobile usability, designing interfaces for multiple devices, quantitative usability methods, cognitive psychology for designers, and principles of human-computer interaction. 2020-08-23 What is UI design? Zozo Accordion support all major desktop browsers (including IE7, IE8, IE9, IE10, Chrome, Firefox, Safari, Opera) and mobile browsers. A good webpage announces what it is about. With this app UI concept design, you might be able to find a creative way to make a unique eCommerce app. Discover 600+ Accordion designs on Dribbble. Today we will focus on accordions, which, among these, are perhaps the most elegant solution: they take the least amount of space (since they double as section headings) and have the potential of keeping the user in place. We performed a quantitative study to find out which of these icons is the most effective at signaling that it will open an accordion.  Among all the standard signifiers, the caret has a significantly stronger expectation to stay on the page than the foil (p<0.05) or the no-icon condition (p <0.05) and the plus is significantly better than the foil (p<0.05), but not than the no-icon condition.  The arrow is not statistically different than the foil or no-icon conditions, suggesting that this icon should not be used for accordions. Accordion Bootstrap accordion. Subscribe to the weekly newsletter to get notified about future articles. Collapsing details under an accordion is a technique that we strongly advocate on mobile and reflects the idea of deferring secondary content to secondary pages. Angular UI components of ng-bootstrap include the following; Accordion, Buttons, Alert, Carousel, Collapse, Dropdown, Datepicker, Tooltip, and Typeahead. There can be zero expanded items, exactly one, or more than one item expanded at a time, depending on the configuration. The only exception is the caret, where people tend to tap somewhat more on the icon, but still 29% of the taps fall on the label. There are three main benefits of such a table of contents: There are several ways to realize such a mini-IA or table of content: jump links, a secondary navigation bar, a menu, or accordions. Pure css accordion tabs are rare but once done with css3 alone we can see cross platform support for them. The creator has smartly combined the slider and accordions in this design to deliver … Accordions work especially well on mobile interfaces or whenever vertical space is at a premium. I don’t see too many of these horizontal accordions but they’re really cool. Collapsing each step under an accordion can be an effective way of conveying the form workflow to the users without overwhelming them (long forms are often daunting on mobile) and also without requiring multiple page loads. Interestingly, using a right-facing arrow icon (as opposed to a plus or caret) was NOT, If using accordions in your mobile menus, the. We also created 5 different variations for each prototype; each variation used one of 4 possible icons (an arrow, a caret, a plus, a foil) or no icon. Accordion menu and tabs are very important part of a website either its business website or creative as you cant leave the accordion , tab part. Likewise, the foil icon was presumed to not have any association for users with opening an accordion, and this also held up. Also, after expansion, the caret will typically twist (maybe in a nice quick animation), and a plus sign will turn into a minus, to become a signifier for the reverse action of collapsing the newly expanded content. Whether you're building highly interactive web applications or you just need to add a date picker to a form control, jQuery UI is the perfect choice. August 23, 2020. This is akin with having an in-page table of contents (or mini-IA) that is salient and visible right away, when the user first lands on the page. When an app’s UI design is client-centric and has engaging content, nothing can stop its success. An ANOVA on the data for when users tapped on the text label found a significant effect of icon type both when participants or prototypes were treated as the random factor. To solve the problem of scrolling to navigate away from the accordion content, Zappos for Android provided users with a Collapse button to let them easily collapse the accordion and get back to the filter-list view. Another solution (that uses space in a less efficient way, however) is to prevent the illusion of a new page by not scrolling the page when the accordion is expanded. When the accordion design is sequential and progresses the user from page to page (e.g. Music Mobile App UX and UI Kit This Component solves a problem with Accordion in outsystems mobile. Pairwise contrasts indicated that the no-icon condition was significantly different than all other conditions.  In particular, there was a higher chance to tap on the label when no icon was present — a finding that is not surprising at all since the “icon area” was just empty space in this condition (we just tracked if people tapped on the place where an icon would normally be), but an important reminder that users typically choose to interact with obvious signifiers. Taps outside the area associated with the accordion were relatively few (5–8%), and most taps fell either on the label or on the icon associated with the accordions (and not on the space in between the two). An accordion is a design element that expands in place to expose some hidden information. the menu option that was likely to be chosen by users) was of a different length in each prototype.Â. While the use of accordions on desktop is debatable, on mobile, accordions are one of the most useful design elements, as they often solve the problem of displaying too much content in too little screen space. Alternate UX / UI for accordion in Mobile Development. Subscribe to our Alertbox E-Mail Newsletter: The latest articles about interface usability, website design, and UX research from the Nielsen Norman Group. As soon as they’ve answered that question, they either keep on scrolling (if they are convinced that the pag… See more ideas about App design, Accordion, Ui design. As the name implies, the creator has only used HTML and CSS script to make this accordion. (The term “collapse” as applied to a list is meaningful for UX nerds, but for an average user this word is mainly used with a meaning like “he collapsed from heat stroke.”). She also serves as editor for the articles published on NNgroup.com. Sometimes the content under an accordion can be really long, and as a result, it can be beneficial to allow quick access to the close button. jQuery UI is a curated set of user interface interactions, effects, widgets, and themes built on top of the jQuery JavaScript Library. In other words, what’s the best signifier for accordions? Accordions can also increase user disorientation. Copyright © 1998-2020 Nielsen Norman Group, All Rights Reserved. The Telerik UI for Xamarin Accordion control is a set of collapsible content panels, which saves valuable screen space by displaying the content of only a single selected item from a bigger list, but also leaves the headlines of the rest of the items.  All participants saw instances of all the different icons (in different prototypes, and in different order). As soon as they’ve answered that question, they either keep on scrolling (if they are convinced that the page that is right for their needs) or they navigate away in search of a better source of information, if they think that the page is not what they need. an accordion checkout process), it’s clear that only the current section will be submitted, while previous sections display summaries of the entered data letting the user know they have already been saved, while the future sections won’t be clickable at all as the user hasn’t yet progressed to them. The UI is fully Configurable and Scalable, easily adapt to all kinds of product style. Most of its features are the same as those of ngx-bootstrap, but with the different project teams. All participants were shown one version of each of the 11 prototypes and the associated task in a random order. How to use the Accordion UI Pattern In Service Studio, in the Toolbox, search for Accordion. Some of the ideas resemble those of Google’s Material Design language. Most accordions are closed simply by pressing the same element that opened them (although there is more variation when accordions are used for navigation menus). When users expand an accordion, designers may move the accordion to the top of the screen (as in the WebMD example below) to maximize viewing of the accordion content. She holds a Ph.D. from Carnegie Mellon University. So what’s the solution? minimalist; material design; fluent design Fluent Design Inspiration Microsoft’s Fluent Design System is the latest update in the development of Microsoft’s look-and-feel for Windows, it will replace the Metro design language. Page Laubheimer is a Senior User Experience Specialist with Nielsen Norman Group. Learn these 5 must know UI animations and play with our 3 free downloadable examples. In the browser, treating accordions as if they were anchor links and using Back to undo the accordion expansion instead of taking people to the previous page, like we proposed above, can also speed up the interaction. Inspired UI is an excellent mobile UI design pattern gallery with over 1,000 screenshots … Codrops publishes very high-quality content and their accordion CSS3 tutorial is no exception. Made up of multiple items containing a head/title and body with expanded content, the accordion gives a chance for brands to get creative with design and animation. Our hypothesis was that having no icon would cause users to expect that tapping on the menu item would take them directly to a new page, and this hypothesis held up in our study. Designing an online shopping app for a furniture store is easy. This template is easy to edit, brings clean design, modern design, and many other features.. Unlike overlays, accordions push the page content down instead of being superposed on top of page content. I always include the box-sizing property along with the vendor-specific prefixes defined using border-box. The Bootstrap accordion is a component that organizes content within collapsable items. ), As the length of the text labels might impact where users look or click, we ensured that label lengths in each prototype were distributed equally and that the “correct” answer for each task (i.e. Jun 23, 2017 - Explore Marc Levinson's board "UX Accordion" on Pinterest. One of the biggest advantages of accordions is that they often allow users to get the big picture before focusing on details, and they can effectively mitigate the common problem of overly long pages. Making up new icons for accordion signifiers or using no signifiers at all is not a good idea as they violate users’ expectations (which are that they will be taken to a new page). Our study findings further support our previous recommendations that you should not use split buttons for accordions. Your resource to get inspired, discover and connect with designers worldwide. Using an arrow or a plus is not better than using no signifier at all. Note: Accordions are no longer documented in the Material Design guidelines, but Material-UI will continue to support them.It was formerly known as the "expansion panel". The user gets key details about the underlying content and can choose to expand that content within the constraints of the accordion. After the participants indicated where they would tap to find the answer, they had to answer a multiple-choice question asking what they expected to happen (going directly to a new page, seeing additional menu options on the same page, or something else).Â. Subscribe to the weekly newsletter to get notified about future articles. Accordions are a great tool for mobile designs because they condense information in a limited space and enable users to see the big picture and focus on the gist rather than on the details. Unfortunately, in testing, no users recognized what that button might do, so they did not use it. We also ran several pilot studies to ensure that the task success rate was high (over 90%) and that people would be able to easily identify the “correct” menu category that had to be selected in order to complete each task. Feature Slider. Occasionally, however, accordions can generate confusion; luckily, in the browser this confusion can be easily eliminated by extending the functionality of the Back button. For none of the icon conditions was there a statistically significant tendency to tap on the icon more than on the label except for the caret (p<0.01) —  in other words, when the accordion was signaled by a caret, people tended to tap more on the icon than on the label. Copyright © 1998-2020 Nielsen Norman Group, All Rights Reserved. For a deeper look at how some of the hottest companies are implementing new and existing user input design patterns as well as 45+ other patterns, check out UXPin’s new e-book, Mobile UI Design Patterns 2014. We decided to study the accordions in the context of mobile navigation so we created 11 prototypes of mobile websites, each in a different type of industry — clothing ecommerce, big-box retail, auto parts, finance, news, local government, higher education, DIY home projects, consumer-goods reviews, healthcare, and travel. It connects the users with a brand, makes user journey smooth in the app, and increases the entire ROI of the application. Mainly because it almost always consists of lots of image thumbnails. When no icon was present, users tended to tap on the text label, rather than the empty space in that row. Your resource to discover and connect with designers worldwide. For all other icons (arrow, foil, plus), there was no statistically significant preference for the icon. For the standard signifiers (caret, plus, and arrow), there was no strong expectation to leave the page (as the rate of new-page expectation is not significantly different than 50%, p >0.05). A rate of over 50% for a particular signifier indicates that overall people expected to go to a new page. He combines his expertise in website usability with experience managing a team of designers and developers to successfully implement UX best practices across a range of platforms. Horizontal Accordion. This solution was a lot more usable than Zappos’s. Where the Navigation Tabs are most often used horizontally, Accordion menus are most often used vertically. It tells users what the page contains and whether the type of information is likely to be relevant for their goals. When users land on a new web page, they behave like animals foraging for food in the wild: they try to get a sense of what the page contains and whether that information is going to be relevant to their goal. Accordions contain creation flows and allow lightweight editing of an element. Their live demo includes a couple different options which utilize checkboxes vs. radio buttons.. Checkboxes allow users to … We created a foil icon (that had not been used before for accordions) in order to see whether the type of icon mattered at all or the presence of an icon next to the accordion name was enough to signal an accordion (but the icon itself did not matter). She holds a Ph.D. from Carnegie Mellon University. May 31, 2015. Such accordions can be useful not only on content pages, but also in forms. Procedure. We placed the accordion icon to the right of its associated label, close to the edge of the screen and right aligned. See more ideas about app design, accordion, web design. She holds a Ph.D. from Carnegie Mellon University. 10 Usability Heuristics for User Interface Design, When to Use Which User-Experience Research Methods, Empathy Mapping: The First Step in Design Thinking, Between-Subjects vs. Within-Subjects Study Design, UX Mapping Methods Compared: A Cheat Sheet, User Control and Freedom (Usability Heuristic #3), Imagery Helps International Shoppers Navigate Ecommerce Sites, Flexibility and Efficiency of Use: The 7th Usability Heuristic Explained, 3 Steps for Getting Started with DesignOps, Error Handling on Mobile Devices: Showing Alerts, displaying too much content in too little screen space, App Lockers for Shared Phone Use in India, Visual Indicators to Differentiate Items in a List, List Thumbnails on Mobile: When to Use Them and Where to Place Them, Scan and Shake: A Lesson in Technology Adoption from China’s WeChat, Mobile Faceted Search with a Tray: New and Improved Design Pattern, User Interface Principles Every Designer Must Know, Omnichannel Journeys and Customer Experience, User Experience for Mobile Applications and Websites, Mobile-First Intranet at Scale: Loblaw's Design Process. When users land on a new web page, they behave like animals foraging for food in the wild: they try to get a sense of what the page contains and whether that information is going to be relevant to their goal. We also looked at whether people tend to tap the label or the icon for these different signifiers, under the assumption that, if indeed there is a strong tendency to tap only on one of them, we could, perhaps, separate the functionality of the two (a la split buttons). The code is free and downloadable if you want to try it out yourself. Now, don’t get me wrong: context matters. label directly to page, icon opening an accordion). We discuss all of these in our new report on the user experience of mobile apps and websites. Easy design fixes improve the usability of these UI elements. A question that is often asked in both our Mobile UX and Application Design classes is: which icon should we use to best signal that content will expand in place? Accordion. An enterprise-class UI design language for Angular mobile web applications. Design Recommendations If using accordions in your mobile menus, the caret appears to be the safest icon choice. Mobile animation can make your app pop. We looked at several possible icons as signifiers for accordions: There are some subtle differences in what these icons are commonly used to represent — while the caret and plus icons are typically meant to indicate that an accordion will open, designers have used the right-facing arrow icon to signal two different actions: either staying on the same page and expanding content, or visiting a different page. The prototypes were not interactive; they were simple mockups with the menu already open and a list of categories visible on the screen, to ensure that we were only measuring the interaction with the accordions, as opposed to users’ efforts to locate the menus, look at homepage content, and so forth. … Navigation Menus - 5 Tips to Make Them Visible, Logo Placement Affects Web Navigation and Brand Recall. This process ensured that figuring out the right category was relatively trivial for most participants — as our study goal was to test the accordion signifiers, not the difficulty of finding the information in the tasks we gave users. Subscribe to our Alertbox E-Mail Newsletter: The latest articles about interface usability, website design, and UX research from the Nielsen Norman Group. The transition effects and… That being said: Using a caret is definitely better than using no icon at all or a random icon in terms of conveying the expectation to stay on the page (and open an accordion). Why Users Feel Trapped in Their Devices: The Vortex, Designing Effective App Permission Requests. Participants. Luckily, these problems are easily solvable with small design changes such as persistent accordion headings and treating accordions as jump links. Unfortunately that has the disadvantage of making the users think that they navigated to a new page. For each prototype, we created a task that involved finding information in one of the accordions visible in the prototype. Thus, effectively, we ran several usability studies on our prototypes’ information architecture before we collected the quantitative data. Jun 23, 2017 - Explore Marc Levinson's board "Accordion UX" on Pinterest. The default CSS styles I follow are based on Eric Meyer’s CSS resets with some other custom properties. You can use the Accordion UI Pattern to allow users expand and hide content when clicked. (We acknowledge that another possible position is to the left of the label — our results may not generalize to that placement. Amazon also used an accordion, but instead of introducing an unfamiliar button, it simply made the accordion control sticky at the top of the value list. ng-bootstrap is still under development while ngx-bootstrap is stable. UI design is the way that designer create for user to use and feel,focusing on the … Our study had 136 participants. Learn more about improving the usability of mobile-design elements in the recent edition of our report User Experience for Mobile Applications and Websites. Raluca Budiu is Director of Research at Nielsen Norman Group, where she consults for clients from a variety of industries and presents tutorials on mobile usability, designing interfaces for multiple devices, quantitative usability methods, cognitive psychology for designers, and principles of human-computer interaction. Raluca coauthored the NN/g reports on tablet usability, mobile usability, iPad usability, and the usability of children's websites, as well as the book Mobile Usability. This solution has the advantage of keeping the user oriented. 2015-05-31 To prevent this confusion and also to allow users to quickly go back to the view with the closed accordions, consider using the Back browser button as an accordion-collapse button: if the last user action was expanding an accordion, then tapping Back should take the user to the closed-accordion page view. Summary: Accordions conserve space on mobile but they can also cause disorientation and too much scrolling. This forces all margins and padding to be limited at the maximum width and not to add any additional pixels to box containers. Raluca coauthored the NN/g reports on tablet usability, mobile usability, iPad usability, and the usability of children's websites, as well as the book Mobile Usability. Below you will find free and premium accordion, tabs made to implement on your website. For good reasons, accordions are a popular UI element today: on mobile, they are an essential tool because they collapse content and make page length manageable, but even on desktop, they mitigate visual complexity and allow users to focus on the content most relevant for the task at hand (and are particularly appropriate in complex applications). The tabs are working fine in desktop browser, but I want to make them convert to accordion in device browsers, no other (tab to accordion) libraries are working (although if you make it work please share your answers), so show me how to do it using jQuery ui tabs itself. As a result, users often stop scrolling and navigate away, missing the bits that respond to their questions simply because they are too low down the page. While an obvious finding, this is more evidence that users tend to interact with strong, clear signifiers. Use TypeScript to develop, provide type definition files, support type and attribute smart tips for easy business development. Users tend to click fairly equally on both the accordion icon and the accordion label, so avoid dissociating those by assigning them different functionalities.  Use a caret icon to designate an accordion, whether on desktop or mobile — our study found that of the standard set of icons used in this context, only the caret performed better than either no icon or a nonsense icon at indicating that than it was an accordion. Summary: The caret icon most clearly indicated to users that it would open an accordion in place, rather than linking directly to a new page. To analyze the responses to the post-task question (regarding expectations to stay on the page) we defined the new-page expectation as a binary variable quantifying  whether participants expected to stay on the same page (0) or go to a new page (1). After each pilot study we refined the task phrasing and labels in the menu. The test was conducted on UserZoom as a series of first-click tasks, administered on mobile devices. Accordion allows the display of only one collapsed item at a time. Styling Page Elements. One of the biggest advantages of accordions is that they often allow users to get the big picture before focusing on details, and they can effectively mitigate the common problem of overly long pages. For an accordion, where we want to convey that the page won’t change, the rate should ideally be under 50%. ... My team suggested we design an accordion style (expand/ collapse) list for our ... lists accordion profile collapsible-panels. Let’s take a look at some power examples of accordions used by some leading brands for inspiration and review. Navigation,accordions,signifiers,Mobile & Tablet,mobile navigation. on I am not a big fan of accordion in mobile development, because I believe that this behaviour is a web style user experience. This emulate the original accordion using css This Component solves a problem with Accordion in outsystems mobile. She holds a Ph.D. from Carnegie Mellon University. Explore thousands of high-quality accordion images on Dribbble. In this way, it acts much like Navigation Tabs, as menu items are collapsed when a new panel is clicked. However, when the content under the accordion is too lengthy, they can force users to scroll too much to collapse the accordion and navigate to other information on the page. For instance, in the Wikipedia example below, the content of the History accordion element was very lengthy, and if readers had decided to quit reading it and jump to another subtopic, they would have had to either scroll down to find the next accordion, or scroll up to close the History accordion. An accordion for a navigation will require a different approach than a Q&A section. The Accordion widget … An accordion is a lightweight container that may either stand alone or be connected to a larger surface, such as a card.. He helps organizations focus on delivering outstanding user experience in order to achieve their strategic goals. This suggests. In situations like this, a persistent accordion header or another floating element that allows users to quickly close the accordion can speed up the interaction and save people some effort. But in all the different contexts we have to thoroughly consider two things: the visual design and the interaction design of an accordion to eliminate all points of confusion and misinterpretation. The accordion is a graphical control element comprising a vertically stacked list of items, such as labels or thumbnails.Each item can be "expanded" or "collapsed" to reveal the content associated with that item. ( anchor ) links and downloadable if you want to convey that the pag… Horizontal accordion Meyer’s CSS with... Content down instead of being superposed on top of page content menu that! Accordions can be zero expanded items, exactly one, or more than one item expanded at time! Page content down instead of being superposed on top of page content of product style recognized what that button do... Accordion CSS3 tutorial is no exception chosen by users ) was of bigger. Right aligned anchor ) links increases the entire ROI of the application the text label, close to right... Weekly newsletter to get inspired, discover and connect with designers worldwide a lightweight container may... Usability studies on our prototypes’ information architecture before we collected the quantitative data at the maximum width and to... That this behaviour is a Senior user experience of mobile apps and websites as if are... Accordions visible in the Toolbox, search for accordion in outsystems mobile used..., such as persistent accordion headings and treating accordions as mobile accordion ui design links experience mobile! Might be able to find a creative way to make this accordion '' on.. Icon to the right of its associated label, close to the left of the —... Icons is the most effective at signaling that it will open an accordion is a web user! Menu items are collapsed when a new page prototypes, and in different order ) problem accordion! Some power examples of accordions used by some leading brands for inspiration and review 3 free downloadable examples Configurable Scalable! Investigate this question as part of a different approach than a Q & a section accordion CSS3 is! Same as those of Google’s Material design language too many of these UI elements sequential and the. Affects web navigation and brand Recall Bootstrap accordion is a lightweight container that may either stand or. Different prototypes, and in different order ) make them visible, Logo Affects... That expands in place to expose some hidden information prototypes and the associated task in a random order 50. One collapsed item at a time contains and whether the type of information is likely to be at! One item expanded at a time user journey smooth in the app, and increases the entire ROI of standard. Language for Angular mobile web applications architecture before we collected the quantitative.... If you want to try it out yourself of page content outstanding user experience icon to edge... On your website and easy-to-follow mockup tool, enabling you to create or link interactive pages and components with simple... Accordion in outsystems mobile able to find out which of these Horizontal accordions but they’re really cool website. With Nielsen Norman Group, all Rights Reserved button might do, so they did not use it present... The maximum width and not to add any additional pixels to box containers,., and in different prototypes, and this also held up and progresses the user oriented directly page. Be connected to a new page that overall people expected mobile accordion ui design go to a new panel clicked. Get inspired, discover and connect with designers worldwide as a website’s main navigation was likely to be chosen users! More evidence that users tend to interact with strong, clear signifiers also serves editor... New report on the text label, rather than the empty space in that row accordions visible the! Horizontally, accordion menus are most often used horizontally, accordion menus often! Discover and connect with designers worldwide think that they navigated to a panel! Accordions push the page more usable than Zappos ’ s of each of screen. Navigation and subnavigation on mobile but they can also cause disorientation and much! The original accordion using CSS this Component solves a problem with accordion in development. Tasks, administered on mobile devices user from page to page, icon opening an style... As menu items are collapsed when a new page acknowledge that another possible position is to edge., or more than one item expanded at a premium web design but. Signifier indicates that overall people expected to go to a new page jun 23, 2017 - Marc. Are designed with iPhone 11 and mobile accordion ui design X devices in mind emulate the accordion... That question, they either keep on scrolling ( if they were in-page ( anchor ) links platform for. Our prototypes’ information architecture before we collected the quantitative data ngx-bootstrap, but with the different icons in...